A Closer Look at Root Washing

Earlier this year we publish a objet d’art on root wash ( “ Healthy Garden , ” January / February 2020 ) , the drill of get rid of all the ground from a containerized or ball - and - burlapped ( B&B ) plant life prior to plant . This piece generated more than a piddling pushback from plantspeople and experient gardener alike . Internationally renowned woody plant life expert Paul Cappiello , executive theater director of Yew Dell Gardens in Crestwood , Kentucky , offered to help us screen out through the disarray .

Iagree wholeheartedly that root washing prior to planting can distinguish tooth root problems that can then be counterbalance through pruning and the general untangling of existing roots . Root lavation also makes it sluttish to insure that greenhouse plants , which are sometimes planted too deeply at the greenhouse , can be reestablished at the proper depth . But there are some authoritative matter to have it away before one decides to wash the beginning of a new plant .

1 . Not all plants are campaigner . While root washing has its benefits , it has some limitation as well . For one thing , it is surely not for all industrial plant . Some plants have exceedingly finespun and fussy root systems and ca n’t stomach any sort of perturbation when transplant . Others are problematical as nails . Take a forsythia ( Forsythiaspp . and cvs . , Zones 4–9 ) out of its container , throw it on the driveway and run over it with your car , and it ’s quite probable that you could imbed it and have it survive . But have you ever tried transfer a daphne ( Daphnespp . and cvs . , Zones 5–9 ) ?

Forsythia Photo : Michelle Gervais

Daphne Photo : Steve Aitken

Those with a lifespan of gardening experience have acquiredtheir cognition through many days of trial and error . For less - experiencedgardeners or the cosmopolitan public , root - washing testimonial call for to be offered with a grain of forethought and not put up as a cure - all for all plant .

2 . Lack of water system is the independent problem . One common argument in favour of beginning washing is that container plants are most likely to fail because their etymon organisation do not reinstate in the landscape painting . While that may be technically unfeigned , the primary reason those stem systems fail to instal is far less complicated : lack of water . Again , the experienced gardener might water a plant sufficiently , but the huge bulk of container - develop industrial plant consume home from the garden center each springtime are purchased by people with little experience . They often do n’t realize that container plant in the nursery are irrigated sometimes two or three times a 24-hour interval . It is not rare for inexperienced gardeners to be surprised at learning that they have to water their newfangled industrial plant more than once a week .

3 . Success bet on the gardener . Another title in favour of root washing is that bareroot plants are more likely to establish than container - grown plants . I have to disagree completely . sure enough , in a university inquiry project or at the hands of an experienced gardener that might technically be true . But one of my nongardening Quaker or neighbors turned promiscuous with a trunkful of bareroot plants is not a formula for success . From require impale to engraft depth to manipulation and lachrymation , there are just way too many variable to overtake with bareroot plants .

4 . young flora take TLC.The term “ transplant shock ” sounds bad because it is bad , but it is real . When we dig up a works from a sphere greenhouse , and even when we get finished beating up a container - grown plant life ’s root system , we ’ve effected a major insult on that plant . It is usually miss a mammoth portion of vits original root system . Anything we can do to pass to customers at the garden center that these plants will demand some prison term in the horticultural ICU blend in a foresighted mode toward teach them that unlike our desktop printers , plants are not plug and meet .

5 . Top growth is important . You might have heard that container and B&B plants with intact antecedent organisation ( rather than source - washed systems ) push out more top emergence because the roots have n’t been trouble and the plants need those resource to go to settle growth rather than top increment . But this clearly misses the fundamentals of plant sugar physiology . Research done decades ago institute that only the very early and initial flush of source and shoot growth is supported by stored reserve . The residue , and in fact the vast majority of growth throughout the time of year , is supported by current photosynthetic activity . This means that in rules of order for the plant to maximize radical regrowth after transplant , it want vigorous new top emergence to service as the industrial plant ’s railway locomotive .

6 . Dormancy is the well sentence to steady down wash . Contrary to what reader of this piece may think , I am actually a fan of base lavation . But even with 50 years of experience gardening and conducting research on gardening and plant cultivation , I would seldom — if ever — root wash a plant in full folio . That would file down the margin for error to a razor - tenuous sliver . The immense majority of pee absorption by roots is done by the very finest ascendent hairs , and they are so fragile and delicate that even the most deft hand can and will cause impairment to and/or red of many of those tooth root hairs during the etymon - wash process .

Again , root washing is a majuscule idea in some cases . It is a great way to make indisputable you give your flora a good start and to annihilate circle roots . And anything that catch gardener to look more closely at any part of their plant is a good thing in my book . But it is important to sympathise the why siemens and wherefores so that we typeset ourselves up for success rather than bankruptcy .

If you ’re a beginner but honey to experiment and do n’t mind losing a plant here and there in the process , go for it . If you ’ve killed your reasonable share of plant and now have a good feel for which engraft digest root washing well and which plants do n’t , follow your respectable assessment . An experient hand wash the roots of a bombproof plant during the dormant time of year is the safest choice . An inexperienced nurseryman wash the ascendant of a picky plant in the middle of a July drouth ? That ’s playing with fire .

Fine Gardening recommend Products

A.M. Leonard Deluxe Soil Knife & Leather Sheath Combo

hunky-dory horticulture receives a commission for detail purchase through links on this site , including Amazon Associates and other affiliate ad programs .

Get our latest tips , how - to articles , and instructional videos sent to your inbox .

Signing you up …

Root Rot Identification and Treatment

Be on the Lookout for Root-Knot Nematodes

Root Washing: Why and How to Wash Roots

Caring for Plant Roots: What You Need to Know

connect hunky-dory horticulture for a detached engage live webinar feature Dr. Janna Beckerman , a renowned plant life diagnostician as well as professor emerita at Purdue University and the ornamentals expert manager …

When I spy a particular moxie dollar bill cactus ( Astrophytum asterias ) at the Philadelphia Flower Show a few month ago , I knew I was in trouble . With a delightful colour shape …

When we only prioritize plant we want over plant our landscape needs , each time of year is fill up with a never - end listing of chores : pruning , pinch , watering , treating , remediate , and fertilizing , with …

There is no better way to correct root issues. Root washing, though, means that the plant is going to require some sustained TLC from the gardener. If you are of a “Plant it and walk away” mindset, this practice might not be for you. Photo:Steve Aitken

Video

Touring an Eco-friendly, Shady Backyard Retreat

You must be careful when you enter the backyard of garden designer Jeff Epping — not because you ’re potential to trip on something , but because you might be dive - bomb by a pair …

4 Midsummer Favorites From a Plant Breeder’s Garden

Episode 181: Plants You Can’t Kill

Episode 180: Plants with Big, Bold Foliage

4 Steps to Remove Invasive Plants in Your Yard

All Access appendage get more

Sign up for afree trialand get accession to ALL our regional mental object , plus the rest of the member - only depicted object library .

Start Free Trial

Get consummate web site access to expert advice , regional content , and more , plus the print mag .

bulge your innocent trial

Already a member?sign in

Forsythia Photo: Michelle Gervais

Daphne Photo: Steve Aitken

Nobody knows how dry I am. The biggest factor in getting a plant established in its new home, whether it has been root washed or not, is providing adequate amounts of water. Drip irrigation is a great way to provide a long, steady drink to a thirsty plant. Photo: Steve Aitken

Bare stems and bare roots. While the roots of some plants can be washed in full leaf, the highest rate of success with root washing is when a plant is dormant. Photo: Courtesy of Sandra Merrill